RC Roofing

Repair vs. Replace: Which Is the Better Option for Residential Roofs?

The average asphalt shingle roof can last you only 20 years. With that in mind, when was the last time your roof had a replacement?

If not recently, you may want to consider a replacement. If your roof does not have many issues, then you have the repair vs. replace question for your residential roof.

We are here to help you answer this question.

As you make your way through this post, you will learn what factors to consider when deciding whether you want to repair or replace your residential roof.

What Happens During a Roof Repair?

A roof repair specialist will isolate the portion of your roof where your issue is located. The process itself may only require them to patch a few holes, replace missing shingles, or check your roof for other issues.

What Is Having Your Roof Replaced Like?

A roofing company will strip everything off of your roof to expose its deck. From there, they will determine whether they need to repair your rafters, sheathing, and trusses. If they notice other noteworthy issues, they will let you know.

This process is more complex since it requires more steps. And because of these steps, you can expect it will take at least a few days for your contractor to finish your project.

4 Factors To Consider When Deciding Repair vs. Replace Your Residential Roof

Throughout this section, we will cover various crucial factors you will need to consider when deciding whether you want to repair your roof. Once you finish this section, you will have a better idea of whether spending more money on a roof replacement is worth it.

1. Extent of Your Roof Damage

Roof damage differs among different types of roofing material. These damages also can give you a better idea whether you should repair or replace. First, you have structural damage, which involves missing shingle granules, cracked shingles, and rusted panels.

Depending on the severity of your structural damage, you will want to invest in a replacement.

Otherwise, you have aesthetic damages, which cover moss growth or an aged look. These are not essential to replace unless you are trying to sell your home.

2. Your Roof’s Age

The date your roof was installed and the materials used play a crucial role in determining whether you need a replacement. Even if your roof does not look decrepit, it may have suffered from storm damage in the past. Because of this factor, it may be ready to fall apart sooner or later.

To figure out how old your roof is, you will need to either contact the manufacturer or the previous homeowner.

3. How Long You Will Stay In Your Home

Whether you plan to sell your home soon or intend on staying for another 20 years, you will want to replace roofs that have already gone through several repairs.

Repairing your roof before selling it can increase its curb appeal and recoup over 68% of what you spent on the replacement.

4. Where You Are Located?

Roofing replacements are critical, depending on where you are located. For example, if you are in Tennessee, then you will experience frequent severe storms throughout the year.

To prevent these storms from stripping your roofing or damaging items inside your home, you will want to replace your roof. That is if it is suffering from any damages.

Contract a roofing professional and have them inspect your roof first.

When You Should Repair Your Roof

Repairing your roof can save you money in the short term and help your roof last longer. In these scenarios, you will want to choose to repair over replacing:

  • Leaks: around your chimney or pipe boot
  • Granule loss
  • Home ventilation issues
  • Poor roof installation
  • Missing shingles
  • Cracks on your roof

You will also want to consider the factors that we mentioned above. Consider your situation to help you determine whether you only need repairs.

When You Should Replace Your Roof

If you have the budget, replacing your roof can serve as a worthwhile investment. Whether you want to sell your home or enhance your home’s aesthetics.

Replacing your roof is also a worthwhile option if you live in an area that is susceptible to undesirable weather. Or, if you want to improve your home’s energy efficiency.

Is a Partial Roof Replacement a Better Option?

You will want to avoid partial roof replacements unless you need immediate damage control. Going with these types of replacements will lead to uneven roof appearances.

Repairing half of your roof can also lead to more expenses. For example, there are labor costs. While you save a bit by repairing only some of your roof, specific tasks can drive up your overall cost. Whether you are looking for roof replacements or repairs, RC Roofing can help. Reach out to us for a free quote. Tell us what you need.

RC Roofing

Maryville: (865) 336-2374
Nashville: (615) 753-6877
Top envelopeusertagphonebubblemagnifiercrosschevron-down