Henley Roofing vs RC Roofing Comprehensive Comparison
Choosing a roofing contractor in East Tennessee involves more than just comparing prices. It’s about finding a team that offers expert craftsmanship, dependable warranties, high-quality materials, and a clear, trustworthy customer experience. Two roofing companies that frequently come up in conversations in and around Maryville, Knoxville, and the greater East Tennessee region are Henley Roofing and RC Roofing.
While both companies are established and locally operated, they differ significantly in services, warranty offerings, material selection, and overall capabilities. This article offers a head-to-head comparison of Henley Roofing and RC Roofing to help you determine the right roofing partner for your home or commercial property.
Company Backgrounds
Henley Roofing: Family-Owned Residential Roofing
Henley Roofing is a family-operated roofing business that primarily serves homeowners in the Knoxville and Maryville areas. They focus on traditional residential roofing services, with a reputation for straightforward shingle roof installations and repairs. Henley Roofing markets itself on being community-focused, with a strong emphasis on local service and responsiveness.
While Henley Roofing is dependable for basic roof replacements and repairs, their offerings are narrow in scope, often limited to asphalt shingles. They do not provide commercial roofing, skylight installations, or other specialty roofing systems.
RC Roofing: Full-Service Residential and Commercial Roofing
RC Roofing, based in Maryville, TN, offers a comprehensive suite of residential and commercial roofing services throughout East Tennessee, including Knoxville, Sevierville, Townsend, and Wears Valley. With a skilled team of roofing pros, RC Roofing handles everything from standard shingle roofs to complex metal systems, skylight installations, certified low-slope applications, and more.
RC Roofing is recognized for its:
- Extensive service area
- Versatile residential and commercial capabilities
- Premium material options
- Strong warranties
- Detailed, photo-supported inspections and estimates
You can view their residential and commercial services on their website.
Range of Services
Henley Roofing: Basic Residential Roofing
Henley Roofing’s services include:
- Asphalt shingle roof replacements
- Roof repairs due to age or storm damage
- Basic roof inspections
This makes them a good fit for straightforward roofing needs—especially if you have a smaller residential property with conventional roofing requirements.
However, if your home or building requires custom roofing solutions, skylights, or metal roofing systems, Henley Roofing may not have the expertise or offerings to meet your needs.
RC Roofing: Versatile Roofing Solutions
RC Roofing’s services are expansive and tailored to fit a wide range of properties. Their offerings include:
- Residential Roofing
- Commercial Roofing
- Metal Roofing Systems (Standing Seam, R-Panel, Exposed/Hidden Fasteners)
- Skylight Installation
- Certified Low-Slope Roofing Systems
- Ridge Vent Installation and Attic Ventilation Upgrades
- Emergency Roof Repairs
- Custom Flashing and Waterproofing
- Free Estimates with Photo Documentation (Request a Quote)
RC Roofing’s full-service model ensures you don’t have to look elsewhere, even for specialized or commercial roofing projects.
Warranty Protection
Henley Roofing Warranties
Henley Roofing typically provides standard workmanship warranties, along with basic manufacturer warranties on shingles. These warranties are generally limited and may become prorated over time. While this level of coverage may be sufficient for some homeowners, it doesn’t offer long-term protection or peace of mind for larger or more complex roofing projects.
RC Roofing Warranties
RC Roofing offers industry-leading warranty coverage, including:
- 10-Year Workmanship Warranty on Shingle Roofs
- 5-Year Workmanship Warranty on Metal Roofs
- 50-Year Non-Prorated Manufacturer Warranty (CertainTeed & other premium brands)
This level of protection is a major differentiator. With RC Roofing, homeowners and commercial property owners receive long-term value and reduced financial risk over time, especially in storm-prone areas like East Tennessee.
Materials and Customization
Henley Roofing Materials
Henley Roofing primarily installs asphalt shingles from commonly used brands. Their projects usually involve standard shingle options with limited color or design flexibility. Metal roofing, energy-efficient options, and designer shingles are generally outside the scope of their services.
This simplicity may appeal to homeowners looking for fast, budget-conscious roof replacements but may fall short for those wanting custom finishes or specialty applications.
RC Roofing Materials
RC Roofing offers a wide range of premium materials and customization options, including:
- Architectural and Dimensional Asphalt Shingles
- Standing Seam and R-Panel Metal Roofing
- Cool Roofs and Energy-Efficient Systems
- Certified Low-Slope Materials (e.g., TPO, EPDM, PVC)
- Custom Ridge Vents and Flashings
- Skylights (Velux and custom installations)
Their ability to tailor materials and designs to meet customer preferences and building requirements puts RC Roofing in a league above companies offering cookie-cutter solutions.
Customer Experience
Henley Roofing Experience
Henley Roofing earns good reviews for being local and responsive, especially for quick residential repairs. Many customers appreciate their polite crews and willingness to work with insurance companies for storm damage claims. However, their communication and scheduling can sometimes be delayed during peak seasons.
They also lack visual project documentation or digital estimates, which may leave some clients uncertain during the planning and budgeting phases.
RC Roofing Experience
RC Roofing prioritizes a transparent, customer-first process. Their approach includes:
- Thorough on-site inspections
- Free, detailed estimates with photo evidence
- Clear communication and progress updates
- Clean job sites and professional crews
Their team provides in-depth insights into your roof’s condition and delivers itemized quotes so you know exactly what to expect. You can even view real project results in their roofing gallery.
Service Areas
Henley Roofing Coverage
Henley Roofing is focused on the Maryville and Knoxville areas. They serve local neighborhoods reliably but may not travel far beyond these core locations.
RC Roofing Coverage
RC Roofing serves a much broader region across East Tennessee, including:
- Maryville
- Knoxville
- Sevierville
- Townsend
- Wears Valley
- Alcoa
- Surrounding cities and rural communities
This wider service footprint makes RC Roofing a more dependable choice for customers in smaller towns or outlying areas who still want access to premium roofing services.
Estimates and Inspections
Both companies offer free estimates, but RC Roofing’s process is more comprehensive.
RC Roofing:
- Documents your roof’s current condition with photos
- Provides written, itemized quotes
- Explains materials, warranties, and installation methods in detail
Henley Roofing may offer verbal estimates or hand-written quotes with fewer details, which may suffice for small repairs but could be insufficient for full replacements or insurance work.
Conclusion: Which Roofer Should You Choose?
If you’re a homeowner in Maryville or Knoxville looking for a simple, fast, and affordable asphalt roof replacement, Henley Roofing is a dependable option with a local touch. They’re a suitable choice for small-scale projects and straightforward needs.
However, if you require:
- Custom material options
- Metal or low-slope roofing
- Skylight installation
- Commercial roofing
- Extended warranties
- Thorough inspections and visual documentation
Then RC Roofing is clearly the superior choice. Their ability to deliver high-performance roofing systems with a customer-focused approach sets them apart as one of East Tennessee’s most capable and trusted roofing contractors.
Learn More About RC Roofing
Want to experience the RC Roofing difference? Explore their services and request your free, photo-supported estimate today:
With unmatched service, reliable workmanship, and superior warranties, RC Roofing delivers roofing solutions that stand the test of time.
