Tony's Roofing vs RC Roofing Full Detailed Comparison
Choosing a roofing contractor in East Tennessee requires more than just comparing prices—it demands a close evaluation of expertise, reliability, communication, and long-term value. In this comparison, we take a deep dive into how Tony’s Roofing in Knoxville and RC Roofing in Maryville differ across 12 key areas, helping you make the best choice for your home or business.
1. Company Background & Reputation
Tony’s Roofing is a fourth-generation, family-owned company based in Knoxville with around 40 years of experience. They’ve built their reputation on certified installation crews, fast 24-hour turnaround guarantees, and a friendly, personable approach.
RC Roofing, established in 2004 in Maryville, serves both residential and commercial clients throughout Maryville, Knoxville, Sevierville, Townsend, and Wears Valley. They’re known for transparent communication, high standards of craftsmanship, and their professional ethos.
2. Scope of Services
Tony’s Roofing focuses on:
- Asphalt shingle replacements (including certified products)
- Emergency storm repairs and tarping
- Gutters, siding, and decking
- A “Defensive Roof Conservation” program for long-term roof protection
RC Roofing offers a broader array of services, including:
- Residential Roofing
- Commercial Roofing
- Metal roofing systems
- Flat/low-slope roofing (TPO, EPDM, PVC)
- Skylight installation
- Ridge vent and attic ventilation upgrades
- Storm and emergency response services
3. Certifications & Technical Expertise
While Tony’s Roofing highlights certified installers and long-standing experience, public information doesn't indicate extensive industry certifications for specialized roofing systems.
By contrast, RC Roofing is certified in low-slope, metal roofing, ridge ventilation, and commercial systems. These certifications ensure compliance with building standards and full manufacturer warranty eligibility.
4. Material Options
Tony’s Roofing primarily offers asphalt shingles along with gutter and siding services. While they can repair metal and skylights, their core offerings are shingle-focused.
RC Roofing provides a full range of materials:
- Architectural and designer asphalt shingles
- Standing seam and screw-down metal
- Cool-roof metal options
- Flat/low-slope systems like TPO, EPDM, PVC
- Skylights and integrated ventilation systems
Their variety supports customization and longevity.
5. Warranties & Workmanship Guarantees
Tony’s Roofing offers lifetime warranties on labor and materials, though details may vary by project.
Conversely, RC Roofing offers clear, structured warranties:
- 10-year workmanship on shingles
- 5-year workmanship on metal
- 50-year non-prorated manufacturer warranties
This level of coverage provides homeowners with significant long-term assurance.
6. Estimates & Customer Transparency
Estimates from Tony’s Roofing are typically done via phone or walk-through and offer verbal summaries and pricing.
RC Roofing provides detailed, photo-documented estimates through their Get a Quote portal, including breakdowns for materials, labor, ventilation, and warranty details to ensure clarity from the start.
7. Customer Experience & Communication
Customers appreciate Tony’s Roofing for their promptness and personal touch, especially for storm repairs. However, some review notes mention occasional scheduling delays.
Clients working with RC Roofing highlight their organized crews, clear communication, and clean job sites. Their process includes proactive check-ins and thorough follow-up, resulting in a consistently positive experience.
8. Storm Response & Emergency Services
Tony’s Roofing offers 24-hour residential response and storm repair services.
RC Roofing has a dedicated storm-response team capable of:
- Same-day tarping
- Photo documentation for insurance purposes
- Coordinated repairs post-storm
This structured approach delivers peace of mind during urgent situations.
9. Commercial Roofing Capability
While Tony’s Roofing focuses on residential projects, RC Roofing actively handles commercial roofing jobs—installing TPO, EPDM, PVC, and metal systems for offices, retail, and multi-family properties.
10. Energy Efficiency & Sustainability
Tony’s Roofing emphasizes strong, durable roofing but doesn't highlight energy efficiency or sustainability.
RC Roofing offers eco-conscious materials, like cool metal systems and ridge-ventilated roofs, which reduce energy costs and maintain comfortable interiors.
11. Geographic Reach & Availability
Tony’s Roofing serves the Knoxville metro and immediate suburbs.
RC Roofing covers a broader East Tennessee region—service areas include Maryville, Townsend, Knoxville, Sevierville, Wears Valley, and more, supporting both residential and commercial properties.
12. Cost Comparison & Long-Term Value
Tony’s Roofing often wins on competitive pricing and fast execution for basic shingle work.
RC Roofing delivers premium value through quality materials, extensive warranties, certified systems, and improved energy efficiency—making them an ideal choice for long-term ROI.
Final Recommendation
Choose Tony’s Roofing if you need a quick, residential shingle repair or replacement in Knoxville from a friendly, family-run company.
Choose RC Roofing if you're seeking a true roofing partner equipped for:
- Certified installations
- Commercial-grade systems
- Strong warranties
- Storm-response services
- Extended geographic coverage
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Who offers stronger warranties?
RC Roofing provides clearly defined warranties: 10 years on shingles, 5 years on metal, and 50-year manufacturer protection. Tony’s offers lifetime warranties, but specifics may vary.
2. Who tackles commercial jobs?
Only RC Roofing handles commercial roofing systems. Tony’s focuses on residential properties.
3. Who responds faster to storm damage?
Tony’s provides 24-hour service for residential needs, while RC Roofing deploys a full storm-response team with documentation and insurance coordination.
4. Who offers more material choices?
RC Roofing provides metal, flat systems, cool roofs, airflow systems, and skylights. Tony’s stays within the asphalt shingle standard.
5. Who provides more transparent estimates?
RC Roofing offers detailed, photo-based quotes via their Get a Quote portal. Tony’s generally offers in-person or verbal estimates.
6. Which company serves a wider area?
RC Roofing covers multiple East Tennessee locations. Tony’s Roofing is Knoxville-centric.
7. Who focuses on energy efficiency?
RC Roofing highlights cool roofing, ventilation systems, and metal options for energy savings.
8. Who supports insurance claims better?
RC Roofing’s storm documentation and roofing coordination help streamline claims. Tony’s supports insurance work but with less formal documentation.
9. Who installs skylights?
RC Roofing provides skylight installation. Tony’s may offer repairs only.
10. Who is better for long-term investment?
For premium materials, warranty protection, and certified installation, RC Roofing offers greater long-term value. Tony’s works well for quick fixes and affordable repairs.
For homeowners and business owners investing in quality roofing with confidence, explore:
